Dear visitor, if you know the answer to this question, please post it. Thank you!

Page 2 of 2: Posts 21 - 27 of 27
prev
1 2
 

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/9/11 16:30
Isakaya is a tavern. It's a place to drink alcohol with your hair down (or with your hair bundled, to be physically precise!). Yes, they serve non-alcoholic beverages, but everything is designed for the public drinker. The meal would be relatively salty and oily, and is supposed to taste better with beer or shochu or ji-zake as opposed to vintage wine.

I'm a big drinker. But if I want to have a nice, balanced, authentically Japanese home-cooked meal, and not necessarily something to go great with a drink, I would aim for a "cafe" or a "teishoku-ya" and have water or the free green tea with it.

If I want a nice, fancy authentically Japanese dinner, I might go to a "kappo" or (if I can afford it for a special occasion) a "ryotei" but not an izakaya.

Can I expect a quality meal at a izakaya? Not always, but yes, except that it would be a quality izakaya meal.

Can I expect a quality meal at a "cafe", "teishoku-ya", "kappo" or "ryotei"? Not always, but yes, except that it would be a quality "cafe", "teishoku-ya", "kappo" or "ryotei" meal. But the thing is, while a great number of izakaya today is part of a chain, a lot of "cafe", "teishoku-ya", "kappo" or "ryotei" tend to be run by an indivisual or a family.

As it is in any country, you can expect a "certain" quality at chain restaurants, because their job is to keep the same quality for all their restaurants. But to keep the same quality for all their restaurants, you have to sacrifice a lot, and you can't really do the same thing a mother would do at home.

My main question is basically; is it common to have really nice and nicely prepared lunch specials at izakayas, or are they often a bit hit or miss?

For example, if you're a office worker, everyone in your office would know which eatery serves better food for a reasonable price. But since everybody knows, the eatery would need to accommodate a large number of customers within the short one-hour Japanese lunch time. So, the eatery often ends up being a chain izakaya. The more eager office workers would often try to find time to walk to a further mum-and-pop type eatery to have better opportunities.

In other words, unfortunately, places that serve authentic Japanese home-cooking for non-drinkers are very scarce and they're certainly not open every day. Places with a view are even fewer. Thank goodness they are increasing lately, though. I really hate it when I want to host foreign visitors with decent lunches and end up having to sit at an izakaya.

I wonder if this answers your question too.
by Uco  

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/9/11 20:48
One issue with non-chain izakayas, especially higher-end ones or kappo places, is that they often don�ft serve dinner. But if they do, it�fs not like they are going to use inferior ingredients or have incompetent chefs at lunchtime. So they typically will not drop their standards significantly at lunchtime. But they do often drop their prices and offer teishoku sets at a most appealing price. And you do not need to feel obligated to buy a beverage. I usually just drink the tea they bring.

I wouldn�ft go looking specifically for izakayas as a place to find a great lunch set. Not only izakayas, but also many restaurants that aren�ft izakayas will often have lunch prices that will knock your socks off if your usual currency is not the yen. Daily specials will often include one or more really good teishoku sets.

Unless you are a dedicated �gfoodie�h (which I am definitely not), I think it�fs sort of a waste of time trying to find the ultimate dining experiences in Japan by focusing on specific restaurants or types of restaurants. This doesn�ft mean you shouldn�ft be selective about where you eat, or that it isn�ft worth time looking at reviews (for example, on Google Maps or Tabelog) if you have the time. But devoting a good part of your day to finding, and getting to, a place to eat lunch will take away from the time you have to enjoy other things. And standing in a long queue to get seated is (in my mind) usually not worth the time spent. I mean, the food in Japan is so incredibly good that it�fs like shooting fish in a barrel, and the prices at the current exchange rate (even though it has gotten less favorable just before your trip, it looks like) can make you feel like Alice in Wonderland. Of course, there are plenty of mediocre restaurants, but in general the standards are so high. And you have a huge advantage in that you don�ft typically go to the ultra-famous tourist-magnet locations where it can be harder to get seated at a good restaurant. Your itineraries are more likely to put you where the local people eat, and bad restaurants generally can�ft survive long in such places.

If I had a tip at all, it might be to go early. Some restaurants where I�fve had truly memorable lunches will offer a really special teishoku that they only make a limited number of, like maybe 20 sets, and once those sell out you can�ft get them. But I don�ft typically go out of my way to look for these special deals. I usually eat lunch early anyway, as good places will typically fill up before noon.

I very often make lunch my fanciest meal of the day and then eat a self-catered dinner in my hotel room. If I eat �gdine out�h three meals a day, it can be hard to stick to a fairly healthy diet, and I tend to be in Japan for close to a month, so too much rich food and white rice will take its toll. (This is one reason that these days I tend to pay for breakfast at my hotel, as the spreads very often include numerous healthy offerings including vegetable osozai and almost always grilled fish. I also buy osozai and other items in grocery stores and depachikas. This is not always the cheapest route, but it is easier to pick and choose items that I need to keep my digestive system happy.)

Anyway, that�fs just my own personal take. Natives like Uco and frog1954 have a lot more experience than I do.
by Kim (guest)  

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/9/11 20:53
Whoops, I meant that non-chain izakayas often don�ft serve LUNCH�c (Chain izakayas are more likely to, but will typically be unremarkable.)
by Kim (guest)  

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/9/12 02:49
I agree with Kim about kappo counters being the sweet spot for solo dining. You get that seasonal artistry without the stiff multicourse formality of traditional ryotei. Showing up right at 5:00 PM when doors open has saved me from reservation headaches many times!
by Emi Takahashi09  

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/9/12 07:38
Thanks for the info everyone.

I kind of got my answer which is basically: some izakayas do good lunch but look if it's busy and st other options

Like some others have mentioned above, I might sometimes have a nicer lunch and a basic smaller dinner.
by mfedley  

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/10/2 19:23
Thanks everyone for your replies which have thankfully paid off as my trip quickly comes to an end.

With all of my trips to Japan - I can't believe that I did not know about teishoku which came in great for days I wanted a good lunch but a very simple dinner. Ironically I found that finding izakayas that did lunch (which were not chains) a bit harder to find that I thought - so teishokus really did the trick. And thank goodness for Google Translate as the old mom + pop places can be good.

On my original question - I've learnt that some good research can really pay off when it comes to hotel kaiseki's. Over my 4 weeks in Japan - I had 3 of ryokans/hotels with a kaiseki and all ended up ranging from very good to spectacular.

Something that I rarely do at ryokans is significantly upgrade the dinner - but rakuten had a big sale and there was a nice hotel in the San-In region with good reviews and the highest tier dinner for 17,000 yen which I thought was reasonable.

After looking more into the hotel - the chef currently has this award (Œ»‘ã‚Ì–¼�H ) which I'd honestly never heard of. When I google translated the courses I was impressed with the amount but not so much the ingredients. That was until I actually tried the food. It's was close to the best meal I'd had in Japan and I guess shows that getting the best ingredients (not just big hunks of average wagyu) and doing something with it is all that's needed. (Also - this is the first time that a chef introduced himself to all tables at the end of a meal. Is this common at all as I've never seen it?)

If interested in the courses - its here: https://maps.app.goo.gl/G53iUdKd1i185HaF7

Another place I stayed at was within the grounds of a temple with the main chef being known for Shojin Ryori food and I was not aware that meat/fish like dishes can often taste better than reasonable versions of the real thing. I wish I knew what they made the faux squid sashimi out of - and they somehow made a good vegan version of eel (would have been better with a bit of the green pepper they put on the top).

I'm also happy that I went out of my way and actually tried Matsusaka Beef (it was sukiyaki - but it was good). It's interesting to see how some cooks/chefs are very proud of where they source the food - as he had a bit of info in English about where he got his beef from (made sure I saw it) and then spoke to Japanese patrons in much more detail and you could see the pride/passion when he spoke about it.
by mfedley  

Re: Hotel Kaiseki Vs Restaurant Kaiseki 2026/10/6 18:35
As you've had kaiseki many times, can I recommend you try kappo this time around. For me, I prefer kappo dining, especially if you're on your own.

Kappo is sometimes described as being in between having kaiseki and going to an izakaya. There is an element of truth in that, but you'd have to go to a top-quality izakaya (I've been to many in Japan) for that comparison to be true.

It's more about counter seat dining, where you can watch the chef at work. That makes the whole experience more special for me, than kaiseki, which I also love, but it's more formal.

Osaka is the best and most famous place for kappo cuisine and kaiseki originated from the tea ceremony and Zen Buddhism in Kyoto. It's no surprise to me that a more informal, fun and engaging style of haute cuisine developed in Osaka, with their love of food and it's history of merchants and entertaining guests.

I prefer to leave it to chef when I go for kappo. You'll have all the artistry and seasonal delights of kaiseki, but you can watch the chef at work and if they're not too busy, you can have some conversation.

The best places to have it in Japan are in Minami/Namba and Kitashinchi, both in Osaka. In Minami, there's Naniwa kappo, which is the true origin of kappo cuisine. Kitashinchi has lots of kappo restaurants; however, you may be rubbing shoulders with a male Japanese executive and his companion for the night!

There's no strict rules with kaiseki or kappo dining, apart from basic table manners. Apart from don't wear any perfume or after shave, which should be the case in any fine dining establishment in Japan (and for any dining for that matter).

by FoodToursJapan  

Page 2 of 2: Posts 21 - 27 of 27
prev
1 2
 

reply to this thread