Home
Back

Dear visitor, if you know the answer to this question, please post it. Thank you!

Note that this thread has not been updated in a long time, and its content might not be up-to-date anymore.

Why does this sentence mention name? 2012/12/22 05:05
海岸には508名の女の子がいます。

First, the best way I can translate this is: As for on the beach, there are women of 508 names.

This tells me that I am certainly not reading this sentence correctly. How is this sentence supposed to be read?
by hajime gakusei  

Re: Why does this sentence mention name? 2012/12/22 10:45
海岸には508名の女の子がいます。

名 is also used as a counter for people, so the sentence reads:

508 girls are at the coast.
by ... (guest) rate this post as useful

Re: Why does this sentence mention name? 2012/12/22 21:51
by ez (guest) rate this post as useful

Re: Why does this sentence mention name? 2012/12/23 07:53
Would any of these be wrong?

海岸には508人の女の子がいます。
海岸には508にんの女の子がいます。
海岸には508じんの女の子がいます。
by hajime gakusei rate this post as useful

Re: Why does this sentence mention name? 2012/12/23 11:17
It is a little complicated and let me unclarify for you, lol.


1. is used when the names of each person in the group of people can be identified.
i.e. How many students took the test? 200 mei desu.
2. At a restaurant a group of customers is asked, "nanmei-sama desuka?" how many people? (never nan nin desuka? You might walk away upset being treated rudely.) You reply 3 nin desu, not 3 mei desu.
3. More specific than 人. The capacity of an elevator is written 10 mei max.
4. can be used in the context of lessor societal class order. Also dependent on who is reporting to whom of how many in a group.
There were 4 criminals=犯人は4名いました。


1. is used to report just the quantity of people.
Normally they can be interchangeable.
Confusing, isn't it?
by ay (guest) rate this post as useful

Re: Why does this sentence mention name? 2012/12/23 11:43
hajime gakusei,

"Jin" is the reading for the kanji 人 when you are talking about nationalities and other characteristics of people. For counting the number of people, "nin" is the reading to use.
by AK rate this post as useful

reply to this thread