Which hotel is better

We'll travel to Japan in December for about one week. Help me to decide which hotel is better, between the three hotel below:
1) Park Hotel Tokyo - Shimbashi
2) Crown Plaza Metropolitan - Ikebukuro
3) Keio Plaza - Shinjuku

Most people would say the Keio Plaza, there are dozens of threads on this.

Olla,

Better for what? Price? Comfort? Convenience from Narita Airport? Convenience for sightseeing? Convenience for nightlife? It all depends on your personal preferences, so why not check the individual hotels' websites?

I find the Park Hotel and Keio Plaza equally good. The Keio Plaza better in terms of level of service and hospitality. And the Park Hotel a little bit better in terms of the atmosphere (especially the live jazz in the lobby lounge). Locationwise, both are good but not perfect.

I have not yet stayed at the Crown Plaza in Ikebukuro. It beats the other two hotels in terms of location.

Neither Keio Plaza nor Park Hotel Tokyo is close to JR stations (though they are close to subway stations). My impression is Park Hotel is more for business person/young couples while Keio Plaza is for a family. Park Hotel has a great view of Tokyo tower and located in a futuristic area "Shiodome."

Crown Plaza is right beside JR Ikebukuro station.

I would highly disagree that the Keio Plaza is not close to any JR station. It is a in close walking from Shinjuku Station.

I agree with John. Distance is relative but keio is a 5-10 minute walk from the station. Also, it can be reached by an underground passage when the weather is bad.