Home
Back

Dear visitor, if you know the answer to this question, please post it. Thank you!

Note that this thread has not been updated in a long time, and its content might not be up-to-date anymore.

Confusion 2008/4/1 23:58
Hello everyone. I'll get straight to the point.

I've been having trouble with particles. "O" and "Ni".
I know that "o" is supposed to mark the direct object and "ni" is translated as to, on, or at.

But my problem is, the book I'm studying from gives and example for using "ni".

Nihon ni itta
I went to Japan.

But since Nihon is also the direct object, wouldn't it be:
Nihon o itta????

I really need the help with this since I know this is just the basic stuff.

Arigatougozaimasu minna.
by Curious American  

... 2008/4/2 15:05
No, Nihon is definitely not the direct object in that sentence. Direct object is, for example:

- "apples" in "I eat apples," (Ringo o taberu/tabemasu)
- "Japanese (language)" in "I study Japanese" (Nihongo o benkyo suru/shimasu)
- "a movie" in "I saw a movie" (Eiga o mita/mimashita).
by AK rate this post as useful

ni 2008/4/2 17:06
The way to think of 'ni' is basically as giving information about the nature of the action, not as defining the direct object of it.
itta.
doko ni?
nihon ni.
Tabeta.
nani wo?
ringo wo.
iwareta
dare ni?
reiko ni.

Like that.
by catch2 rate this post as useful

Answers the question "What" 2008/4/2 21:54
The direct object answers to the quesion ''who'' or ''what'':
What did you eat?
I ate an apple.
Ringo wo tabemashita.

What did you read?
I read a book.
Hon wo yomimashita.

If it doesn't answer the question ''What'', then it isn't a direct object.
by Kali rate this post as useful

Arigatou! 2008/4/2 23:54
Arigatou minna-san! You helped me understand this a lot better!
by Curious American rate this post as useful

Also consider 2008/4/3 00:31
When you use "o", something is being done to something else.

nihon ni iku

Nothing is being done to Japan, you're just going to it. Expressing movement is one of the uses of ni.

ringo o taberu

Something is being done to the apples, so O is appropriate here.
by Robuda rate this post as useful

reply to this thread